Which Health Insurance Plan is Right for You?
A simple guide to help you choose between HMO, PPO, EPO, and POS plans
$1,997 vs $2,350
Average yearly premium: HMO vs PPO
Source: 2023 KFF Employer Health Benefits Survey49%
Americans with employer PPO plans
Source: 2023 Healthcare Coverage Statistics$1,300
Average yearly savings with in-network care
Source: 2023 Healthcare Cost InstituteCompare Plan Types at a Glance
| What to Compare | HMO | PPO | EPO | POS |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Monthly Cost | Lower ($166/month)* | Higher ($196/month)* | Medium ($181/month)* | Medium ($183/month)* |
| Need a Primary Doctor? | Yes | No | No | Yes |
| Need Referrals? | Yes | No | Sometimes | Yes |
| Can See Any Doctor? | No** | Yes | No** | Yes |
** Except in emergencies
Understanding Each Plan Type
HMO (Health Maintenance Organization)
Best for: People who want lower costs and don't mind having a primary doctor coordinate their care
Think of an HMO like a home base for your healthcare. You pick one main doctor who helps manage all your care.
Pros:
- Lowest monthly payments ($166/month on average)
- Simple copays - usually $25-30 for visits
- Less paperwork to deal with
- One doctor coordinates all your care
Cons:
- Must stay in network except for emergencies
- Need referrals to see specialists
- Less flexibility in choosing doctors
PPO (Preferred Provider Organization)
Best for: People who want more freedom to choose their doctors and don't mind paying more
A PPO gives you more freedom. You can see any doctor you want, even without a referral.
Pros:
- See any doctor without referrals
- Can go out-of-network if needed
- Don't need a primary care doctor
- More specialists to choose from
Cons:
- Highest monthly payments ($196/month on average)
- Higher out-of-pocket costs
- More paperwork for out-of-network care
- Must keep track of your own care
EPO (Exclusive Provider Organization)
Best for: People who want PPO-like freedom but with lower costs
An EPO is like a mix between an HMO and PPO. You get more freedom but must stay in-network.
Pros:
- Lower costs than PPO ($181/month on average)
- No referrals needed usually
- Don't need a primary care doctor
- Larger network than HMOs
Cons:
- No coverage outside network except emergencies
- Must check if providers are in-network
- Less flexibility than PPO
POS (Point of Service)
Best for: People who want a primary doctor but also want some out-of-network options
A POS plan combines HMO and PPO features. You have a primary doctor but can go out-of-network if needed.
Pros:
- Can see out-of-network doctors
- Primary doctor coordinates care
- Lower costs for in-network care
- Good balance of freedom and coordination
Cons:
- Need referrals for specialists
- Higher costs than HMO ($183/month on average)
- More paperwork for out-of-network care
4 Steps to Choose Your Plan
1. Check Your Budget
Look at how much you can spend each month on insurance. Remember to consider both the monthly payment and out-of-pocket costs.
Rule of thumb: Lower monthly payments (like with HMOs) usually mean higher costs when you get care.
2. Think About Your Doctors
Do you have doctors you want to keep seeing? Check if they're in the network for the plan you're considering.
Tip: PPOs and POS plans let you see out-of-network doctors if needed, but you'll pay more.
3. Consider Your Health Needs
Think about how often you see doctors and if you need specialists. Some plans make it easier to see specialists than others.
Example: If you see lots of specialists, a PPO might save you time and hassle even though it costs more.
4. Look at the Network
Check which hospitals and doctors are in each plan's network, especially ones close to your home and work.
Remember: The best plan is only as good as its network of doctors and hospitals.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
Only Looking at Monthly Costs
Choosing a plan based solely on the monthly premium without considering other costs.
Impact: Could pay thousands more in out-of-pocket costs
Solution: Consider total costs including deductibles, copays, and coinsurance
Not Checking Network Coverage
Failing to verify if your preferred doctors and hospitals are in-network.
Impact: Paying full price for out-of-network care
Solution: Check provider networks before choosing a plan
Ignoring Prescription Coverage
Not reviewing how plans cover your regular medications.
Impact: Unexpected high costs for prescriptions
Solution: Compare drug formularies and coverage between plans
Overlooking Plan Restrictions
Not understanding referral requirements and coverage limits.
Impact: Denied claims and surprise bills
Solution: Learn plan rules for referrals and prior authorizations
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the difference between HMO and PPO plans?
HMOs typically have lower monthly costs but require you to have a primary care doctor and get referrals for specialists. PPOs cost more monthly but give you more flexibility to see any doctor and don't require referrals.
Which plan type is best for families?
The best plan depends on your family's needs. HMOs can be good for families who want lower costs and don't mind having a primary doctor coordinate care. PPOs might be better if you want more flexibility to see different doctors or specialists.
What happens if I see a doctor outside my network?
With HMOs and EPOs, you typically have no coverage outside your network except for emergencies. PPOs and POS plans will cover out-of-network care, but you'll pay more. Always check if a provider is in-network before getting care.
Do I need referrals with all plan types?
No. HMOs and POS plans typically require referrals from your primary care doctor to see specialists. PPOs and most EPOs don't require referrals, giving you direct access to specialists.
Related Guides
Ready to Compare Plans?
Use our tools to compare plans and find the best coverage for your needs